An introduction to the issue of ethics of animal testing
Comparing our current ethical dilemma of animal testing and contrast the same with use of canines as human companions, or use of animals for human safety would raise more doubts about our sincerity and perseverance to the issues raised in our society. The ethics of research involving animals (nuffield council on bioethics) is an independent report on the use of animals for medical science although it looks at the whole issue, it pays particular attention to the ethics, specifically in chapter three. In contrast to cosmetic animal testing whose purpose is to satisfy debateably superficial wants, scientific animal testing is being used to grant people a higher quality of life something we’re unsure about is where kantian ethics lies on this issue. This overview provides a brief summary of the ethical and scientific considerations regarding the use of animals in research and testing, and accompanies a collection entitled animals, research, and alternatives: measuring progress 50 years later, which aims to spur ethical and scientific advancement.
Animal experimentation nonhuman animals are used in laboratories for a number of purposes examples of animal experimentation include product testing, use of animals as research models and as educational tools. Animal testing is an extremely controversial topic with people having most divergent views some people feel that animals should not be used as guinea pigs for experimentation and that all animal testing should be bannedthey feel that animals need to be treated in a humane manner and animal testing is a brutal way of treating them and, hence, should be stopped immediately. In australia 65 million animals are used for research and teaching each year, many in testing cosmetic products animal toxicity tests involve blinding and poisoning animals they are subjectively assessed and the results can vary depending upon the species, age, sex and condition of individual animals. Bernard e rollin, phd is university distinguished professor of philosophy, biomedical sciences, animal sciences, and university bioethicist at colorado state university, fort collins, where he developed the world's first course in veterinary and animal ethicshe is the recipient of the prestigious henry spira award from the johns hopkins center for alternatives to animal testing.
Introduction2 11 genesis of this thought about the ethics of our actions as scientists and engineers for us, this is the major reason why we decided to create and pursue this project after reading prominent anti-vivisectionists, we have come to the conclusion that animal testing is morally and ethically wrong we see that the. Animal experimentation is an important book for all those involved in the conduct, teaching, learning, regulation, support or critique of animal-based research. Ethical issues is it morally acceptable to cause pain, suffering and death to animals the question of defining the moral status of humans and animals often arises in the debate on research involving animals.
The ethics of animal experimentation by stephanie liou 06 jul, 2010 animal research , research and hd , research basics many medical research institutions make use of non-human animals as test subjects. Non-animal testing techniques for medical purposes are efficient and far advanced alternatives to animal testing make use of medical imaging, microdosing, metabolism simulation, biochips, mathematics, visualizations and other methods these advanced techniques give great insight, otherwise not offered by use of animal testing. Animal testing & ethical issues animal testing many toiletries and cosmetics are tested on animals such as rabbits, mice, guinea pigs and even monkeys, causing considerable suffering. Introduction research involving animals has been the subject of intense debate in the united kingdom, the rest of europe and the united states the ethics of research involving animals, which seeks to clarify the debate and aims to help people analyze the scientific and ethical issues the report is the outcome of 2 years of deliberations. Introduction: progress in the animal research war by susan gilbert some years ago, deborah blum, a pulitzer prize–winning science journalist, nailed the divide between scientists who conduct research on animals in the hope of advancing medical knowledge and people who object to that work for being immoral and inhumane.
See all religious studies resources » related discussions on the student room 9 uk universities involved in controversial animal testing » animal testing debate, for or against. A major ethical issue with animal testing is that it mostly involves pain, suffering and discomfort experimenters wherever possible will use anaesthetics but for some types of testing, using a pain reliever can mean an interaction with the drug being tested. Animal testing: cosmetics, biomedical research and ethics june 25, 2014 by robb hollis in difficulty 1 , everyday science , principles of science , science in the news animal testing is an incredibly controversial subject, with strong opinions on both sides. Animal ethics is a term used in academia to describe human–animal relationships and how animals ought to be treated the subject matter includes animal rights, animal welfare, animal law, speciesism, animal cognition, wildlife conservation, the moral status of nonhuman animals, the concept of nonhuman personhood, human exceptionalism, the history of animal use, and theories of justice.
An introduction to the issue of ethics of animal testing
Virtue ethics and care ethics virtue ethics the virtue ethics approach in moral philosophy defends the view that when deciding how to live, we should consider not what would make the world a better place or what norms we should obey, but rather what kind of moral agents we want to be. Animal testing: the destruction of animals animal testing, also known as animal experimentation, is the use of non-human animals in experiments and development project, usually to determine toxicity, dosing and efficacy of drugs before proceeding to human clinical trials (biology online. Xvii the ethics of research involving animals summary and recommendations summary and recommendations i background and introduction issues raised by research1 involving animals have aroused intense debate, particularly in the uk opinion about its necessity, justification and acceptability varies widely. Care ethics and animal welfare daniel engster care theorists have outlined an approach to animal welfare issues that appears to avoid many of the most contentious claims of other animal welfare positions1 the reason to oppose animal suffering from the perspective of care ethics is not.
- The moral status of invasive animal research by bernard e rollin during the 1970s and 1980s, two veterinarians and i conceptualized, drafted, and ultimately, in 1985, persuaded congress to pass federal legislation assuring some minimal concern on the part of researchers for the welfare of laboratory animals [1.
- Animal testing is a highly controversial issue unique to modern science on one hand, knowledge gained from animal studies has spread into nearly every corner of medical research animal testing has lead to the development of numerous antibiotics and vaccines.
The ethics of animal experimentation and the issue would be, so far, inconclusive but it is hardly possible to avoid saying a few words regarding the ethics of the way in which the. Animal research ethics evolving views and practices uthe project s2 introduction | progress in the animal research war • susan gilbert u utility and morality: center for alternatives to animal testing at johns hopkins bloomberg school of public health, reports on the federal. Animal testing kills innocent animals in the cruelest ways such as dissection, poisoning, vivisection, toxicology testing, and other methods to better understand why animal testing is unethical and why it should be limited i will present the pros and cons arguments of animal testing. The research is just as varied as the animals themselves and includes medical, cosmetic testing, defense, genetic, and behavioral research just to name a few this research is done by the government, universities, pharmaceutical companies, as well as other commercial organizations.